Would Ned have executed Karstark?
He would have sentenced him to die and imprisoned him. However, one thing that Ned had, and what Robb didn’t was experience and thus wisdom. After counsel, Ned would have not chopped Lord Karstark’s head off.
Why was Robb Stark beheaded?
George Martin has said that he decided to kill Robb Stark because he wished to keep the story difficult to predict: “I killed Ned because everybody thinks he’s the hero The next predictable thing is to think his eldest son is going to rise up and avenge his father. And everybody is going to expect that.
Why did Karstark kill the Lannister boys?
He is taken hostage and placed in a cell at Riverrun, the seat of the Tullys. Martyn and Willem are murdered inside their cells by Rickard Karstark as vengeance for Jaime’s killing of his son Torrhen.
How many men did Robb lose?
Robb splits his army into two, sending the majority of the infantry and 10\% of his cavalry down the Kingsguard under Roose Bolton’s command. That counts to about 16–17,000. Dead, captured, or disbanded.
What happened to Lord Karstark?
He openly insults the King in the North and claims the war is a lost cause. Remaining true to his honor just like his father, Robb decides that Lord Karstark must die for his treason. Rickard is executed for treason by Robb.
What happened Alys Karstark?
During the Battle of Winterfell, Alys and a group of Karstark archers join Theon and the ironborn in defending Bran. She is killed when the wights overrun the godswood. Her death renders House Karstark extinct.
What happened to Robb Starks body after the Red Wedding?
Robb Stark was dishonourably slain at the Red Wedding alongside many of his loyal bannerman, his wife and his mother. His corpse was defiled by the Freys and Boltons. After he is decapitated his wolf Grey Winds head is stitched to his body and paraded mockingly as the King in the North.
Who betrayed Robb Stark?
Lord Walder Frey
Ned Stark died maintaining his honor. His son died following his heart. On Sunday night, The King in the North’s rebellion to avenge his father came to a heartbreaking conclusion when he was betrayed by the scheming Lord Walder Frey. Yes, Robb Stark (Richard Madden) is dead.
Who did Robb Stark execute?
Hence it was decided that Lord Karstark’s head for the two lives. Since his father had taught him that the man who passes the sentence should swing the sword, Robb took it upon himself to behead Lord Karstark.
Why did Robb send 2000 men?
In the show, Robb sends a small force of 2,000 as a feint against Tywin, while leading the bulk of his armies to face Jaime near Riverrun. In the books, Robb did not intend to sacrifice his infantry by offering it to Tywin, he wanted them to engage Tywin and retreat if things go sour, which is exactly what happened.
How did Robb beat Tywin?
Robb was going to ambush Tywin with his main force and siege with Edmure’s force from behind thus winning the fight but Edmure unknowingly come out of the castle and fought Tywin before they could get into the ambush.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E7zRBGtMmec