Who is better Rommel or Guderian?
All wonderful generals in their own respects. Personally I would say Guderian is a much better tank commander than the other two while Rommel is definitely a much better general commander than the other two, and finally with Manstein being a much more broad strategic commander.
Was Heinz Guderian a good general?
James Corum writes in his book The Roots of Blitzkrieg: Hans von Seeckt and German Military Reform that Guderian was an excellent general, a first-rate tactician and a man who played a central role in developing Panzer divisions, irrespective of his memoirs.
Why did Rommel lose in Africa?
The Axis defeat at El Alamein meant that North Africa would be lost to Hitler and Mussolini. The defeat was due to a variety of factors. These included insufficient Axis numbers, overextended supply lines, and Allied air superiority.
Did Patton and Rommel ever meet?
In real life the two were never involved together in a major confrontation, as Rommel was wounded in 1944 and later forced to commit suicide (due to his association with the anti-Hitler conspirators of the July 20 plot), before Patton had command in large-scale land operations.
Who defeated Rommel in North Africa?
the British Eighth Army
The charismatic Field Marshal Erwin Rommel was comprehensively defeated by the British Eighth Army, and Allied material superiority meant that he had little chance of rallying his broken forces.
When was Rommel defeated in North Africa?
In the famous battle of El Alamein, the British Eighth Army—beginning in October 23, 1942—surprised the German commander with its brute resolve, and pushed him and his Afrika Korps back across and out of North Africa.
What battle did Patton defeat Rommel?
The Battle of El Guettar
The Battle of El Guettar was a battle that took place during the Tunisia Campaign of World War II, fought between elements of the Army Group Africa under General Hans-Jürgen von Arnim, along with Italian First Army under General Giovanni Messe, and U.S. II Corps under Lieutenant General George Patton in south-central …
Did Patton fight Rommel in North Africa?
Patton’s First Victory American troops invaded North Africa in November 1942, but did not face serious resistance until the following February, when they finally tangled with Rommel’s Afrika Korps—and the Germans gave the inexperienced Americans a nasty drubbing at Kasserine Pass. After this disaster, Gen.
What was the difference between Erwin Rommel and Guderian?
Von Manstein, after Hitler’s invasion of France, did lose to the Soviets on the Eastern Front. Rommel was pummelled by Allied forces in Africa, despite his numerous attempts and open battlefield advantage (blitzkrieg heaven). Guderian was, although a large part of the offensive on Russia, an equally good general.
Why was General Guderian such a good general?
Guderian was, although a large part of the offensive on Russia, an equally good general. The reason why I say they changed with the wind is because their circumstances became more and more dire towards the end of the war. Before 1941, Germany had been absolutely obliterating anything in its path; it was not even a contest, mere slau
How did Manstein von Manstein and Rommel change with the wind?
All three changed with the wind equally. Von Manstein, after Hitler’s invasion of France, did lose to the Soviets on the Eastern Front. Rommel was pummelled by Allied forces in Africa, despite his numerous attempts and open battlefield advantage (blitzkrieg heaven).