How do you suggest a potential reviewer for a journal?
Finding peer reviewers – our top tips
- Check the references in the article.
- Use search tools and databases to find researchers working on similar topics.
- Use your editorial board.
- Consider previous authors and guest editors.
- Ask reviewers who decline for suggestions.
- Use predefined keywords.
- Use previous reviewers.
How do I suggest a reviewer for Elsevier journal?
Top tips for working with reviewers
- Try to select reviewers who are doing research in a related area – they are more likely to find the paper relevant and interesting, and therefore respond promptly.
- Make use of editorial board members for reviewing, and consider rotating off board members who do not review regularly.
Why should you be a reviewer?
It shows editors consider you an authority in your field. You’ll keep abreast of research, learn new and best-practice methods, and start examining your own research from that critical vantage point. Peer reviewing helps you to become a better writer, and perhaps ultimately a more successful published author.
What makes a good journal reviewer?
Good reviewers really take their time to provide a valuable evaluation of the work, even if the content is not ready to be published. It is not your job to copyedit, but to evaluate the research for aspects such as originality, appropriateness, and relevance.
What does reviewer mean?
: one that reviews especially : a writer of critical reviews. Synonyms Example Sentences Learn More About reviewer.
How do you suggest a reviewer on a cover letter?
When suggesting potential reviewers, it is advantageous to give 3 or 4 names with contact information (address, affiliation, e-mail address, telephone/fax number), either in the cover letter, or in the appropriate section which can be found in some online submission formats.
How do I get my Elsevier reviewer certificate?
How can I claim my reviewer certificate?
- Download Reviewer Recognition certificates.
- See an overview of your peer review activities.
- Claim 30-day ScienceDirect and Scopus access for accepted reviews.
- Volunteer to review for journals of interest.
Why should I review a paper?
Reviewing papers is a good way to learn new results early. Of course it’s unethical to use results before they’re published, but the reviewers know the results as soon as they’re published. Moreover, the best ideas don’t just give you ideas upon which to build your research, but they change the way you think.
What is the importance of journal review?
A good review paper can clarify the state of knowledge, explain apparent contradictions, identify needed research, and even create a consensus where none existed before. Writing a good review can also help to advance your career. Because reviews tend to be highly cited, they help with recognition and promotion.
How do you review a reviewer paper?
Summary
- Give positive feedback first.
- Briefly summarize what the paper is about and what the findings are.
- Try to put the findings of the paper into the context of the existing literature and current knowledge.
- Indicate the significance of the work and if it is novel or mainly confirmatory.
How can I be a good academic reviewer?
Nonetheless, some tips might prove useful.
- Be professional. It’s called peer review for a reason.
- Be pleasant. Don’t be cruel.
- Read the invite. Most journals now have in their email inviting you to review the paper a link to accept and one to reject.
- Be helpful.
- Be scientific.
- Be timely and swift.
- Be realistic.
- Be empathetic.
What does a journal reviewer do?
Reviewers evaluate article submissions to journals based on the requirements of that journal, predefined criteria, and the quality, completeness and accuracy of the research presented. uphold the integrity of the journal by identifying invalid research, and helping to maintain the quality of the journal.